Human-in-the-loop
HITL and the Epistemic Asymmetry: Why the Reviewer Knows Less About the Agent's Reasoning Than the Agent Knows About the Reviewer's Decision
HITL and the Epistemic Asymmetry: Why the Reviewer Knows Less About the Agent's Reasoning Than the Agent Knows About the Reviewer's Decision
The reviewer sees the agent's final proposal. The reviewer doesn't see the agent's reasoning chain, the agent's uncertainty distribution, or the agent's alternative considerations. The agent sees everything the reviewer does: the decision, the reasoning, the timestamp, the audit trail. The information flows one way. The epistemic asymmetry produces rubber stamps, false confidence, and reviews that can't defend themselves. Here is why the asymmetry is HITL's most fundamental design flaw — and how to fix it.